Firm News
Recognized by Chambers USA for 2025, we don’t just litigate—we control the risk, shift leverage, and position our clients for the win.
Mitby Pacholder Johnson Continues To Strengthen Litigation Bench With the Addition of Johnathan Mondel
Mitby Pacholder Johnson PLLC (MPJ), a Houston-based litigation boutique focused on complex commercial and intellectual property disputes, is pleased to announce that Johnathan “John” Mondel has joined the firm as of counsel.
Mondel is an accomplished commercial litigator whose practice encompasses all aspects of complex business litigation, with a particular emphasis on upstream and midstream oil and gas and energy disputes. He represents clients in high-stakes matters involving underground trespass, retained acreage, royalty disputes, Joint Operating Agreement (JOA) disputes, nuisance claims, property damage, and other complex commercial controversies in state and federal courts and before arbitration panels.
“John is an exceptional trial lawyer with deep experience handling sophisticated energy and commercial disputes,” said Steven J. Mitby, a founding partner of Mitby Pacholder Johnson. “His ability to develop winning litigation strategies, manage complex cases from inception through appeal, and effectively advocate for clients in high-stakes matters makes him an outstanding addition to our firm. As demand continues to grow for experienced trial counsel in the energy sector, John’s background further strengthens our ability to serve clients throughout Texas and across the country.”
Mondel has extensive experience managing every stage of litigation, from early case assessment through trial and appeal. He regularly drafts and argues dispositive motions, discovery motions, pretrial filings, trial briefs, mandamus petitions, and appellate briefs while developing litigation strategy and overseeing complex third-party document reviews. He has taken and defended numerous fact and expert witness depositions, including technical experts in trade secret litigation and accountants in royalty underpayment disputes, and has prepared witnesses for trial in complex commercial matters.
Throughout his career, Mondel has played a significant role in several notable energy and construction disputes. Most recently, he presented and directed two fact witnesses and an expert witness during a complex construction arbitration before an American Arbitration Association® panel. Thanks to Mondel’s advocacy, the panel recently issued an eight-figure award in favor of his client. He also served on the trial team in a landmark underground trespass case that resulted in one of the Top 15 Verdicts in Texas in 2023, where he conducted expert and fact witness depositions and examined and cross-examined expert witnesses at trial.
His experience also includes representing clients in multiple royalty underpayment disputes involving both oil and gas and wind energy projects. In addition, he drafted an amicus brief on behalf of an industry association addressing ownership of produced water before the Eighth Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court of Texas.
Mondel has substantial appellate experience as well. He served as the principal drafter for briefing before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit involving the Deepwater Horizon Court-Supervised Settlement Program and helped prepare and coordinate a petition for certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court involving the Carmack Amendment.
Before entering private practice, Mondel served as a law clerk to the Honorable Edith Hollan Jones of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit and the Honorable Robert B. Kugler of the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey.
“I am excited to join Mitby Pacholder Johnson and collaborate with a team known for its exceptional trial work and client-focused approach,” Mondel said. “The firm’s reputation for handling complex commercial and energy litigation aligns perfectly with my practice, and I look forward to helping clients navigate their most challenging disputes.”
Mondel earned his Juris Doctor from Stanford Law School, where he received Gerald Gunther Prizes for Outstanding Performance in Legal Research and Writing, and White Collar Crime. He served as Senior Finance Editor of the Stanford Law Review and Editor-in-Chief of the Stanford Law & Policy Review. He was also president of the Federalist Society and a Bradley Fellow with the Stanford Constitutional Law Center.
He received his Bachelor of Arts in Government and Public Policy, summa cum laude, from the College of William & Mary, where he was recognized as a James Monroe Scholar.
Steven Mitby Recognized in the 2026 Legal 500 U.S. –Houston Elite Rankings

The Legal 500 U.S. Elite program highlights exceptional U.S. lawyers beyond Big Law who handle top-tier work in their respective cities, enabling clients to find the best at a regional level. Selection is based on a rigorous research process that includes in-depth interviews with practitioners, peer and referee feedback, and an analysis of impactful transactions and cases.
For more than three decades, Legal 500 has provided trusted legal market intelligence, ranking top firms and attorneys across more than 150 jurisdictions.
Mitby Pacholder Johnson Partner Steven Mitby Assists in Securing Major Federal Circuit Victory for Versata Software
Houston trial attorney Steven Mitby, founding partner of Mitby Pacholder Johnson (MPJ) PLLC, was part of the legal team that secured a significant appellate victory for Versata Software before the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Versata Software Inc. v. Ford Motor Co. (Case No. 2:15-cv-10628, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan).
On May 22, the Federal Circuit upheld a jury verdict awarding more than $82 million in breach-of-contract damages to Versata and ordered a new trial on unjust enrichment claims. The ruling revives the possibility that Versata could ultimately recover up to $1 billion in damages related to claims involving Ford’s alleged misuse of Versata’s proprietary automotive software technology.
“This ruling validates the jury’s findings and represents a significant victory for our client after years of hard-fought litigation,” said Steven Mitby. “We were proud to help present a compelling case demonstrating the value of Versata’s technology and the importance of enforcing contractual and intellectual property rights.”
For the appeal, Mitby served as co-lead appellate counsel alongside Dan Webb of Winston Taylor LLP (f.k.a Winston & Strawn LLP) in Chicago. Additional counsel for Versata included Jeffrey A. Lamken of MoloLampken LLP in Washington, D.C.; Jennifer Fischell, Michael G. Pattillo Jr., Thomas Schubert, and Eugene A. Sokoloff of MoloLampken in Chicago; Matthew R. Carter and Samuel Zuidema of Winston Taylor in Chicago; Jaye Quadrozzi of Varnum LLP in Birmingham, Michigan; and Sharoon Saleem of JonesSpross, PLLC in Austin, Texas.
Throughout the litigation, Mitby handled critical aspects of the case, including key depositions, summary judgment motions, pretrial motions, and liability analysis that proved instrumental to the outcome. At trial, Versata’s legal team presented testimony and technical evidence that demonstrated Ford had copied and misused Versata’s software technology to save substantial warranty, recall, and vehicle design costs.
The team also successfully simplified highly technical issues for the Detroit jury and used cross-examinations of Ford’s corporate representative and technical expert to challenge core components of Ford’s defense.
Mitby previously served as co-lead trial counsel for Versata in securing a $104.6 million jury verdict against Ford Motor Company for trade secret misappropriation and breach of contract.
The dispute arose from Ford’s long-term licensing relationship with Versata dating back to the 1990s, involving Versata’s automotive-configuration software known as ACM. Versata alleged that Ford improperly used the company’s proprietary technology to develop an internal “like-for-like” replacement system after the parties’ licensing agreement ended.
In the original verdict, the jury awarded Versata $82.3 million for breach of contract and $22.4 million for trade secret misappropriation. Although the district court later reduced portions of the damages award, the Federal Circuit reinstated the breach-of-contract damages after finding the jury had calculated those damages with reasonable certainty. The appellate court also directed further proceedings regarding trade-secret-related damages. A copy of the Federal Circuit ruling can be found here.
Debbie Simon Pacholder Named to Women We Admire’sTop Women Leaders of 2026

Mitby Pacholder Johnson PLLC is pleased to announce that founding partner Debbie Simon Pacholder has been named to Women We Admire’s The Top Women Leaders of 2026, a recognition honoring accomplished women whose leadership, expertise, and impact are helping shape organizations and communities across a broad range of industries.
According to Women We Admire, this year’s honorees are recognized for delivering measurable results while demonstrating technical expertise, sound judgment, and a proven ability to strengthen the institutions they lead. The annual list highlights women from business, healthcare, science, public service, education, nonprofit organizations, law, and other sectors whose leadership continues to drive meaningful progress and set high standards within their professions.
“Debbie’s recognition is a testament to the exceptional leadership, strategic insight, and dedication she brings to her clients and our firm every day,” said Steven Mitby, founding partner of Mitby Pacholder Johnson. “As a founding partner, she has helped build a firm known for excellence, integrity, and results. We are proud to see her accomplishments recognized on a national stage.”
Pacholder is widely respected for her legal acumen, client advocacy, and commitment to achieving successful outcomes in complex matters. Throughout her career, she has earned the trust of clients and colleagues alike through her thoughtful counsel, practical problem-solving, and unwavering professionalism.
“I am honored to be included among such an accomplished group of women leaders,” said Pacholder. “This recognition reflects not only my own efforts, but also the support of my partners, colleagues, clients, and mentors who have contributed to my professional journey.”
Women We Admire noted that while progress toward gender parity in leadership remains uneven, the influence of women leaders is evident in the organizations they guide, the programs they develop, and the communities they serve. The 2026 honorees exemplify the growing impact of women whose decisions shape the future of their industries.
To view the full list, click here.
About Women We Admire
Women We Admire provides news and information on today’s women leaders in business, entertainment, sports, medicine, law, and many other fields. The organization highlights the achievements of exceptional women while inspiring others to pursue leadership opportunities and reach their full potential. Women We Admire distributes its content to more than 70,000 individuals and businesses.
Steven Mitby Recognized in Chambers USA Guide 2026 for Commercial Litigation
Mitby Pacholder Johnson is pleased to announce that founding partner Steven J. Mitby has been recognized in the recently released Chambers USA 2026 Guide, earning a ranking in Commercial Litigation in Houston and Surrounding Areas for the first time.
Mitby is the founding partner of Mitby Pacholder Johnson, a litigation boutique focused on complex commercial and intellectual property disputes. He has built a reputation as a formidable trial lawyer, representing businesses and individuals in high-stakes litigation against some of the largest companies in the world.
Throughout his career, Mitby has tried more than 20 cases and is known for his relentless advocacy and trial-ready approach. His commitment to securing favorable outcomes for clients has earned him recognition among Texas’ leading litigators, including membership in Texas Lawyer’s prestigious “Ten Million Dollar Club,” an honor reserved for the select group of trial advocates who have secured verdicts of $10 million or more at trial.
Sources interviewed by Chambers USA 2026 praised Mitby for his strategic insight, trial skills, and ability to distill complex issues into clear, effective litigation strategies. Interviewees noted that “Steven is great at understanding a new business and industry very quickly, identifying the needs of the clients and developing a winning strategy,” and described him as “an excellent trial and litigation lawyer” who is “very good at simplifying complex issues.” Sources also highlighted that “Steven is smart, works hard and effectively, and is a strategic thinker at every stage of a case,” while others characterized him as “creative, sharp and smart” and “fantastic.”
Chambers and Partners is widely regarded as one of the leading legal ranking organizations in the world. Its annual rankings are based on extensive independent research and interviews with clients, peers, and members of the business community. Chambers evaluates attorneys on a range of factors, including legal knowledge, experience, effectiveness, client service, and commitment to their practice areas.
Mitby Pacholder Johnson’s Founding Partners All Named as 2026 Texas Super Lawyers

Mitby Pacholder Johnson PLLC is proud to announce the firm’s three founding partners, Steven J. Mitby, Debbie Simon Pacholder, and Timothy Johnson, have been recognized by Texas Super Lawyers® for 2026. Mitby has been recognized by Super Lawyers since 2015 and, prior to that time, was named a Super Lawyers Texas Rising Star. This recognition reflects their continued excellence in the Houston legal market and beyond.
Introduced in 1991, Super Lawyers is a rating service of outstanding lawyers from more than 70 practice areas. Each year, less than five percent of attorneys are selected as “Super Lawyers.” To be selected for inclusion, candidates are nominated by peers within and outside the firm and are evaluated on 12 indicators of peer recognition and professional achievement. After the patented selection process is complete, results are validated by a third-party organization, resulting in a credible, comprehensive, and diverse listing of outstanding attorneys.